As Marianne wrote: if you give it to a new mom, or - even more so - a mom-to-be, she is likely to consider it preposterous, especially since the author is a champion of formula. But when the breastfeeding problems are so serious you need to switch to formula, or the baby just won't sleep, this is a gem. The book is uneven, but the good bits are invaluable. It contains really specific tips and schedules re: feeding and napping I have not encountered anywhere else (still, such specific tips and plans may not work equally well for everyone), explains the connection between very consistent - yet doable - feeding and napping schedule and sleeping through the night.